Stable power control for optical transmission systems

ABSTRACT

In an optical transmission system, an optical signal is transmitted to an optical element which is sensitive to changes in the optical power of the signal. Changes in optical power are anticipated and damped by controlling the transmitter output power, or an external damping element. For WDM systems, wavelengths can be added or removed without causing rapid changes in total power which would otherwise disturb the output of downstream optical amplifiers, and cause bit errors.

RELATED APPLICATION

This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No.08/735,759, filed Oct. 23, 1996 now U.S. Pat. No. 6,031,647. Thatapplication has been allowed.

FIELD OF THE INVENTION

The present invention relates to methods of operating opticaltransmission systems, to methods of controlling transmitters, to methodsof controlling an optical power damping element, to optical transmissionsystems, to transmitters, and to damping systems.

BACKGROUND TO THE INVENTION

The power level of an optical signal in an optical transmission systemlimits the distance between regenerators or amplifiers, and needs to becontrolled carefully to avoid errors in the detected bits.

A signal with too high an optical power is subject to nonlinear effectsin the fibre such as Self-Phase-Modulation that can seriously degradethe signal. This causes bit errors or loss of frame in the signal. Thesenonlinear effects are especially severe at bit rates at and above 10Gb/s. The onset of the nonlinear degradations can be quite sharp, inthat only one or two dB of increase in power level can push a signalfrom optimum performance to a failed state.

A signal with too low an optical power is subject to noise degradationsafter attenuation by the optical link.

Erbium Doped Fibre Amplifiers can cause amplitude transients whenamplifying several wavelengths at once. Consider the simple example oftwo wavelengths. If one wavelength is removed while the pump powerremains constant, then the output power at the other wavelength willincrease by 3 dB. The speed of this transient is determined by the pumppower and by the response of the erbium doped fibre, and is measured inmicroseconds.

Addition of a second wavelength causes a similar 3 dB drop in the outputpower of the first wavelength present.

In a wavelength division multiplex system new wavelengths commonly needto be added to systems that are in service. This may be due to anupgrade or may be caused by replacing a unit. Wavelengths also need tobe removed when replacing a unit or reconfiguring the system.

Rapid changes in the power of an optical signal at one wavelength canmove another signal away from its optimum power level towards too highor too low a power. Power margin must be allocated in the design of theoptical system so that during a worst case transient, when combined withother worst case conditions, the data remains error free.

Allowing this margin reduces the available performance of the system,for example, reducing the maximum allowed amplifier spacings.

Various optical elements are sensitive to power changes, includingreceivers. Even if remaining within an appropriate static power range,rapid power transients can still cause bit errors. For example if thetransient is faster than the response rate of automatic gain control ina receiver then the receiver electronics could be momentarilyoverloaded. These distortions can cause errors. During a transient theelectrical signal, at the decision comparator will be larger or smallerthan anticipated. The eye between logic levels will move, which placesthe decision threshold at the wrong location in the eye which causes biterrors.

Furthermore, amplitude transients can cause phase transients in clockrecovery circuits that can exceed allowable jitter ranges, even to theextent of causing bit errors.

It is important that the signals carried by the wavelengths other thanthose being added or deleted remain error free.

It is known from U.S. Pat. No. 5,088,095 (AT & T) that gain clamping byout-of-band lasing in an optical amplifier can improve further theresponse to power transients in that amplifier. However, this requires alot more pump power than a normal amplifier which is expensive toprovide.

It is also acknowledged in U.S. Pat. No. 5,088,095 (AT & T) that it wasknown to stabilise amplifier output by detecting power changes at anamplifier input, and induce opposing compensatory changes in the pumppower control circuitry.

Cooling an optical amplifier in liquid nitrogen has been shown inJournal of lightwave technology vol. 13, No 5, May 1995, pages 782-790“Inhomogenously Broadened Fibre-Amplifier Cascades for TransparentMultiwavelength Lightwave Networks” by Goldstein et al, to allowseparate saturation of the different wavelengths and so suppressescrosstalk of the power transient between wavelengths. However this isnot practical for field equipment.

These three methods attempt to eliminate or minimise the transienteffect of one channel on another in an optical amplified system, byimproved gain control, once the transient reaches the sensitive element.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

The invention aims to improve on such methods. According to a firstaspect of the invention there is provided a method of operating anoptical transmission system, comprising the steps of: transmitting atleast one optical signal to an optical element which is sensitive tochanges in the optical power of the signal; determining that the opticalpower is going to change; and damping the change in the signal input tothe element, in response to the determination.

In contrast to the conventional methods, by determining that the opticalpower is going to change, and damping the change, the system performancecan be improved, and power margins reduced, since power changes aresuppressed before they reach the sensitive elements.

Advantageously, an instruction to change the power level is intercepted.This enables the instructed change to take place gradually, to reducethe disturbance which may be caused by the change.

Advantageously the determination of change is carried out by measuringthe optical power, and extrapolating from the measurement. This enablesunforeseen changes to be damped before they cause disturbances.

Advantageously the optical signal comprises a plurality of wavelengthsand the damping step involves damping of one or more wavelengthsindividually. This enables the total power to be maintained withoutdisturbing changes. Notably, optical amplifiers are sensitive to changesin total power. Advantageously a power change in one wavelength band isdetermined, and the damping step comprises the step of damping thechange in total power by applying a gradually reducing compensatingchange to the power level of at least one other of the wavelength bands.This means the compensating change, which may be rapid, can be dividedacross a number of wavelengths, or that a dummy wavelength band can beused purely for the purpose of maintaining a stable overall power.

Advantageously the damping step involves controlling the output power ofan optical source of the optical signal. This means existing controlcircuitry can be used with little modification.

Advantageously the method further comprises the step of controlling anoutput power of the optical source using a control loop with apredetermined maximum rate of change, wherein in the damping step iscarried out with a lower rate of change.

Advantageously the optical element is an optical amplifier and themethod further comprises the step of controlling the amplifier poweroutput in response to the power in a subset of the wavelength bands.This enables the power margins to be reduced further.

Advantageously the method comprises the step of determining a desiredrate of damping, according to the amount of change and a desired time tocomplete the change. This enables the rate of damping to be controlledto suit the circumstances.

Advantageously the damping step comprises the step of controlling thepower level of a stabilising optical signal, to compensate for thechange.

According to another aspect of the invention, there is provided a methodof controlling a transmitter of an optical transmission systemcomprising the steps of: determining when an instruction to change anoutput power of the transmitter has been received; and changing theoutput power according to the instruction, at a rate slower than a usualresponse rate of the transmitter. This enables undesirable rapid changesto the damped.

According to another aspect of the invention, there is provided a methodof controlling an optical power damping element in an opticaltransmission system comprising the steps of: determining when there isan optical power change at the input to the element; and damping thechange by allowing the output of the element to make a correspondingchange, but at a slower rate. This enables rapid changes in poweralready transmitted, to be damped.

According to another aspect of the invention, there is provided anoptical transmission system comprising: means for transmitting anoptical signal; an optical element which is sensitive to changes in theoptical power of the signal; means for determining that the opticalpower is going to change; and means for damping the change in the signalinput to the element, responsive to the means for determining thechange.

According to another aspect of the invention, there is provided atransmitter for an optical transmission system, comprising: means fordetermining when an instruction to change an output power of thetransmitter has been received; means for converting the instruction toan instruction to change the output power of the transmitter at a rateslower than a usual response rate of the transmitter.

According to another aspect of the invention, there is provided adamping system for an optical transmission system comprising: means fordetermining an optical power change at the input to a controllableelement; and means for controlling an output of the element to allow acorresponding change at the output, but at a slower rate.

According to a last aspect of the invention, there is provided a methodof operating a multiplexed optical transmission system for transmittinga plurality of optical signals, and comprising an element sensitive tochanges in optical power, the method comprising the steps of introducinga stabilising signal into the optical path upstream of the element; and

controlling the power of the stabilising signal to compensate forchanges in power levels of at least some of the other signalstransmitted.

This can be carried out with or without damping, and can enable areduction in transients and a constant overall power to be achieved.

Advantageously, the stabilising signal is used to carry information.This improves the overall bandwidth over the case where the stabilisingsignal is a dummy.

Advantageously such information is carried at a lower rate, which mayallow the receiver to cope with greater power transients. Alternatively,or as well, the information may be carried at a lower rate, or withgreater redundancy, to enable improved error handling.

It will be apparent to a skilled person that the advantageous featurescan be combined with each other and with any aspect of the invention asdesired.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

For a better understanding of the invention, and to show how the samemay be carried into effect, examples of the invention will now bedescribed with reference to the drawings, in which;

FIG. 1 shows an embodiment of the invention in schematic form;

FIG. 2 shows an alternative embodiment of the invention in schematicform;

FIG. 3 shows a transmitter of FIG. 2 in more detail, in schematic form;

FIG. 4 shows a flow diagram of a power control method according to theinvention;

FIG. 5 shows another example of a power control method according to theinvention;

FIG. 6 shows another optical transmission system showing features of theinvention; and

FIG. 7 shows another example of the invention in schematic form.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

FIG. 1 shows an optical transmission system including optical sources 1,2, a wavelength division multiplexer 3, and an optical amplifier 4.Normally, the optical amplifier would be needed at a distance of tens orhundreds of kilometres down the link, to overcome the attenuation causedby optical fibre making up the optical path. Numerous amplifiers may beincorporated, according to the distance covered by the transmissionsystem, between the source 1,2 and a receiver (not shown). In principle,the invention can be applied to systems using a single wavelength band,or using other types of multiplexing such as polarisation multiplexingor time division multiplexing.

FIG. 1 also illustrates a power set point control means 5, provided foreach of the optical sources (normally lasers). A fade-in/fade-outcontrol means 6 is illustrated, feeding the power set point controlmeans. The fade-in/fade-out control means is operable in response to apower level change determining means 7.

In practice, the functions of the set point control 5, the control means6 and the determining means 7 may be carried out within a conventionalmicro controller. The fade-in/fade-out control means may be operable togradually vary the set point for the output power of one of the opticalsources, according to an external stimulus.

This external stimulus may take the form of an instruction to switch offone of the optical sources, eg for maintenance or reconfiguration. Inthis case, a sudden switch off might produce sufficient change in thetotal optical power, to disturb the optical amplifier, and cause biterrors. Accordingly, the micro controller, controlling either or both ofthe optical sources would gradually reduce the set point for the outputpower of the appropriate optical source.

The stimulus for a change could also come from other sources, such asalarm signals indicating that a particular optical source may be at somerisk of failing. The stimulus could also come from detectors whichindicate that maintenance personnel are beginning to extract a cardcontaining an optical source, for maintenance or replacement.

In these later two cases, it might be appropriate for the rate of changeof the power set point to be relatively rapid, for example one or twoseconds, to ensure that the fade out is complete before the opticalsource fails, or is disconnected.

Otherwise, the fade-out could be extended over the course of around 60seconds, to allow automatic gain control circuits to adjust the pumppower of the optical amplifier for example, and thus minimise thelikelihood of bit errors.

A gradual fade in of the set point of the output power can be initiatedin a corresponding way. For example, when it is detected that theoptical source has been re-connected, or when alarms have switched off,or when an instruction to add a wavelength is given.

FIG. 2 shows an alternative embodiment. Transmitters 21 and 22 includepower control functions. The optical output of the transmitters arepassed to attenuators 23, 24 before being passed to a wavelengthdivision multiplexing function 25. A total power controller 27 is fed bythe optical tap 26. To maintain the total optical power at a stablelevel, the total power controller controls the attenuators 23, 24,and/or the individual output power controllers for the transmitters 21,22. The total power controller, and the individual transmitter powercontrols may be implemented using a conventional micro controller. Theattenuators 23, 24 may act as damping elements, to damp any change inoutput power. Accordingly, prior to switch on of a transmitter, anattenuator could be controlled to pass virtually nothing. After switchon of the transmitter, the attenuator could be gradually controlled soas to allow a gradual increase in signal output power. Correspondingly,if a transmitter is to be switched off, prior to the switch off, theattenuator 23 could be controlled so as to gradually reduce the outputsignal power.

Furthermore, compensation for transmitter 21 having its power levelchanged, could be carried out by controlling the attenuator 24,associated with a different wavelength. For example, when transmitter 21is to be switched on, attenuator 24 could be controlled so as to reducethe power output of the signal originated from the other transmitter,transmitter 22. This illustrates how the last aspect of the inventioncould be implemented, without necessarily determining that a powerchange is going to happen, and without necessarily damping the change.The compensation is carried out using one or more of the wavelengthbands as a stabilising signal. Clearly it is not essential to useattenuators to control the power of the stabilising signal. For example,the output power of the laser could be controlled as will be describedbelow.

Of course, although only two transmitters are shown in FIG. 2 and onlytwo optical sources are shown in FIG. 1, there could be many more, andsimilar principles of operation would apply.

FIG. 3 shows in schematic form the principal hardware elements involvedin controlling the output power of a laser. A laser 31 feeds an externalmodulator 32, whose output is fed via a optical tap 33. A smallproportion of the optical signal is fed back via an optical toelectrical conversion stage 34 (usually a P.I.N. diode). Amplificationusually follows, before a A to D converter 35 which feeds the microcontroller 36. This provides the micro controller with valuescorresponding to the output power of the laser. The power values may beupdated at a rate of tens of kHz, or hundreds of KHz. The microcontroller, operating at a clock rate of several MHz, or tens of MHz cancarry out control algorithms to adjust the output power of the laser, bycontrolling its bias current. A digital to analogue converter 37converts the output of the micro controller into analogue form, foramplification by an amplifier 38. The micro controller 36 may have otherinputs, to received instructions from another overall controller,controlling a number of lasers, for example operating at differentwavelengths, feeding a multiplexing device in a W.D.M (WavelengthDivision Multiplex) system. Furthermore, the micro controller mayreceive inputs from mechanical sensors indicating if the transmitter isbeing disconnected or dismantled, and it may receive inputs from alarmsignals generated on the same card, from other hardware elements shownin FIG. 3, or from other parts of the optical transmission system, eventhose at remote locations.

FIG. 4 shows a flow diagram showing some of the control steps to becarried out by the micro controller of FIG. 3, or by a correspondingcontroller for a damping element such as the attenuator shown in FIG. 2.

The first step involves determining if the output power level is to bechanged. As discussed, this can involve checking various inputs to themicro controller. Next, the amount of the total change in level may bedetermined. This step may be unnecessary, if the output is simply tofollow the input but at a different rate of change. The amount ofdesired change may nevertheless be useful in the next step, ofdetermining the rate of change. This may involve checking inputs to themicro controller, to see if there is an urgent alarm, which might merita more rapid rate of change than a normal switch on/switch offsituation. From the rate of change, the amount of change for the currentcycle can be determined. The loop gain K is set to achieve the desiredrate of change.

The next step is to alter the power level output by the transmitter, byfirst of all altering the set level, at a desired rate. A control loopthen tries to achieve the new set level. The timing of this control loopshould be set so that it runs at least ten times as fast as the loopcontrolling the power set level, so that phase changes in one loop donot affect the other loop.

The loop back to change the set level again may be exited after a giventime or a given number of iterations, or, as shown in FIG. 4 byascertaining that the change has been completed.

FIG. 5 shows in schematic form the particular example of how the microcontroller may react to a switch-off instruction. After detecting suchan instruction, the set point of the transmitter can be controlled tofade off gradually, as shown in FIG. 4. Finally, the optical source inthe transmitter can be switched off.

FIG. 6 shows an optical transmission system including a transmitter 11,an attenuator 12, and a receiver 13. The attenuator 12 is controlled bya control means 14. The control means 14 is operable in response to afade-in/fade-out control means 15. The fade-in/fade-out control means isitself operable according to the optical signal power level detected atthe input to the attenuator 12, or the output of the transmitter 11. Theattenuator 12 or an equivalent damping element, may be located anywherein the optical link, before an optical element which is sensitive topower changes, such as the receiver 13, or an optical amplifier.Electrically controllable attenuators using faraday rotation might besuitable and have been announced recently by Fujitsu.

The control means 14, and the fade-in/fade-out control means 15 can beimplemented by a conventional micro controller, and associated circuitryas described above.

Although not illustrated, the attenuator could be controlledadditionally on the basis of a intercepted instruction to thetransmitter to change the power level. Conceivably the fade-in/fade-outcontrol means could be operable in response to the signal power measuredat the output of the attenuator, as well, or instead of the powermeasured at the input to the attenuator. The response time of thecontrol means 14 and the fade-in/fade-out control means 15 will befinite, and therefore the attenuator may be unable to completely dampextremely rapid transitions in power level. Nevertheless, it will have abeneficial effect for a range of types of power level transition whichmight otherwise disturb sensitive optical elements downstream.

FIG. 7 shows in schematic form some of the features of the invention. Adamping means 73 is provided in the optical path, leading to an opticalelement 71 which is sensitive to changes in the power of the opticalsignal. The damping means which may be incorporated in the transmitteras an alternative, or as well as being in the optical path, iscontrolled by a control means 74. The control means 74 is responsive tomeans for determining a change in the optical power, 72. The change canbe determined by extrapolating from measurements of optical power or canbe ascertained from instructions to change the power level, or fromdetecting alarms which indicate conditions which may lead to a change inpower level.

In the embodiments described, where the optical element is an opticalamplifier, the pump power of the optical amplifier may be controlled inresponse to the power measured in a subset of wavelength bands in theoptical signal. If the subset is chosen to be those bands which areclosest to upper and/or lower power thresholds, then the total power canbe controlled with reduced power margins. This is described in somedetail in another U.S. patent application by the same inventor, entitled“Power control for optical element” (ref ‘Roberts 14’), U.S. Pat. No.5,969,840, incorporated herein by reference.

Other variations within the scope of the claims will be apparent to askilled man.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method of operating an optical transmissionsystem, comprising the steps of transmitting data traffic on at leasttwo optical signals to an optical element which is sensitive to changesin optical power of the signal; determining that the optical power of atleast one of the signals is going to change; and damping the change inthe power of at least one of the signals input to the element, inresponse to the determination so as to reduce a likelihood of a biterror in the data traffic on at least one of the optical signals.
 2. Themethod of claim 1 wherein the determination of change is carried out byintercepting an instruction to change the power level.
 3. The method ofclaim 1 wherein the determination of change is carried out by measuringthe optical power and extrapolating from the measurement.
 4. The methodof claim 1 wherein a plurality of signals at a plurality of wavelengthbands are transmitted and the damping step comprises damping of one ormore of the wavelength bands individually.
 5. The method of claim 4wherein a power change in one wavelength band is determined, and thedamping step comprises the step of damping the change in total power byapplying a gradually reducing compensating change to the power level ofat least one other of the wavelength bands.
 6. The method of claim 1wherein the damping step comprises the step of controlling the outputpower of an optical source of the optical signal.
 7. The method of claim6 further comprising the step of controlling an output power of theoptical source using a control loop with a predetermined maximum rate ofchange, and wherein the damping step is carried out with a lower rate ofchange.
 8. The method of claim 1 wherein the optical element is anoptical amplifier and wherein a plurality of wavelength bands aretransmitted, the method further comprising the step of controlling theamplifier power output in response to the power in a subset ofwavelength bands.
 9. The method of claim 1 further comprising the stepof determining a desired rate of damping, according to the amount of thechange.
 10. The method of claim 1 wherein the damping step comprises thestep of controlling the power level of a stabilizing optical signal, tocompensate for the change.
 11. A method of controlling a transmitter forone of a plurality of optical signals of a multiplexed opticaltransmission system for carrying data traffic comprising the steps of:determining when an instruction to change an output power of thetransmitter has been received; and changing the output power accordingto the instruction, at a rate slower than a usual response rate of thetransmitter so as to reduce the likelihood of a bit error in the datatraffic on at least one of the optical signals.
 12. A method ofcontrolling an optical power damping element in an optical transmissionsystem for carrying data traffic comprising the steps of determiningwhen there is an optical power change at the input to the element; anddamping the change by allowing the output of the element to make acorresponding change, but at a slower rate than the rate of the changeat the input so as to reduce a likelihood of a bit error in the datatraffic.
 13. An optical transmission system comprising: means fortransmitting data traffic on at least two signals; an optical elementwhich is sensitive to changes in the optical power of the signal; meansfor determining that the optical power of at least one of the signals isgoing to change; and means for damping the change in at least one of thesignals input to the element, responsive to the means for determiningthe change so as to reduce a likelihood of a bit error in the datatraffic on at least one of the optical signals.
 14. A transmitter forone of a plurality of optical signals of a multiplexed opticaltransmission system, comprising; means for determining when aninstruction to change an output power of the transmitter has beenreceived; and means for converting the instruction to an instruction tochange the output power of the transmitter at a rate slower than a usualresponse rate of the transmitter so as to reduce a likelihood of a biterror in the data traffic on at least one of the optical signals.
 15. Adamping system for an optical transmission system comprising: means fordetermining an optical power change at the input to a controllableelement; and means for controlling an output of the element to allow acorresponding change at the output, but at a slower rate than the rateof the change at the input.
 16. A damping system for an opticaltransmission system for carrying data traffic, the damping systemcomprising: circuitry for determining an optical power change at theinput to a controllable element; and circuitry for controlling an inputof the element to allow a corresponding change at the output, but at aslower rate than the rate of change at the input so as to reduce alikelihood of a bit error in the data traffic.
 17. A method of operatingan optical transmission system comprising the steps of: transmitting atleast one optical signal to an optical element which is sensitive tochanges in the optical power of the signal; determining that the opticalpower is going to make a switched change; and damping the change in thepower of signals input to the element, in response to the determination.18. A damping system for an optical transmission system comprising:means for determining a switched change in optical power will occur atthe input to a controllable element; and means for controlling an outputof the element to allow a corresponding change at the output, but at aslower rate than the rate of the change at the input.
 19. Apparatus fora multiplexed optical transmission system for transmitting a pluralityof optical signals, the system comprising an element sensitive tochanges in optical power, the apparatus comprising: a signal generatorfor introducing a stabilizing signal into the optical path upstream ofthe element; and a controller for controlling the power of thestabilizing signal to compensate for changes in power levels of at leastsome of the other signals transmitted.